Free Consultation 877.583.2524
We do not handle social security disability claims
logo celebrating

Nationwide Leaders in Disability Insurance Law

shook hands

Insurer Was Arbitrary, Capricious For Not Ordering Medical Exam

Monday, April 23rd, 2018

A federal appeals court has found that an insurance company should not have denied a short-term disability claim based on a clearly diagnosed hereditary disease without first ordering an independent medical examination (IME). In our last post, we wrote about the financial importance of short-term disability or STD benefits to a claimant who is unable to work. 

The impairment

Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome Type III or EDS is associated with fatigue and with severe and chronic pain from joint dislocation and subluxation as well as from loose connective tissue. The claimant, a 42 years old woman, has been repeatedly diagnosed since childhood with this disease by her treating and consulting doctors, who have also said it is disabling to her. For these reasons, the court held that the insurer’s STD denial without having referred the claimant for an IME was arbitrary and capricious. 

The plan 

In Guest-Marcotte v. Life Insurance Company of North America, an opinion from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, the Court considered the claimant’s STD application under a plan supplied by her employer, an engine-part supplier, for which she worked as an insurance risk manager. Eligibility for disability under the plan meant that the claimant could neither “perform the material duties of [her] Regular Occupation” nor earn 80 percent of her earnings in her Regular Occupation. 

The administrative record 

One of claimant’s doctors is a recognized EDS expert. He confirmed the diagnosis, joint pain and fatigue, recommending she take short-term disability to rest, undergo “multiple consultations” and start “recommended therapies.” She submitted the STD application, which the insurer denied three times and the federal trial court affirmed. 

Throughout the application and appeals processes, she submitted numerous medical-provider statements, records and reports. Her doctors said that her ability to concentrate, sit and drive were limited. 

On the other side, the insurer had its own medical experts review the records and they repeatedly concluded that there was no “objective” or “quantifiable” medical evidence of disability. One reviewer said that the restrictions her doctors recommended were not “supported by documented impairment.” 

Arbitrary and capricious decision-making process 

Under the STD plan, the insurer may pay for and require that the claimant undergo an IME. The court said that under ERISA it can be evidence of arbitrary and capricious decision-making when the insurer dismisses complaints of chronic pain without ordering an IME. 

On that basis, the court sent the claim back for proper consideration by the insurance company. It is important to note that the decision to seek an examination is often explored by Courts, with mixed results.

Jason A. Newfield

Written By:

Jason A. Newfield - Disability Insurance Attorney

Jason Newfield is a founding partner of the disability insurance law firm Frankel & Newfield. He has spent the majority of his legal career advocating for the rights of disabled workers. He has lectured other professionals, worked on a Federal Advisory committee, and published many articles in the field of disability insurance claims and litigation.

Learn more about Jason | See Jason’s Publications



Ready To Talk?

Fill out the form to request a FREE legal consultation

Sorry, we do not handle SSDI/Social Security claims.

Frankel & Newfield does not currently handle any Social Security Disability Insurance claims.


*Required fields are marked

I have read the disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


This is about a Social Security Disability claim.

Ipad image

Download Our Free eBook


Secrets the Disability Insurance Companies Don't Want You to know!

Sign Up for our mailing list to receive disability insurance law updates

Your information is 100% secure and will never be shared with anyone


No matter where you are nationwide, we are here to help.

We have the resources and support to take on the largest insurance companies.

Contact us today for our nationwide service.

Contact Us
Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi Missouri
Nebraska Nevada New Hampshire New Jersey New York North Carolina North Dakota Ohio Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina
South Dakota Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming