Free Consultation 877.583.2524
We do not handle social security disability claims
logo celebrating

Nationwide Leaders in Disability Insurance Law

shook hands

Federal Court of Appeals Reverses Decision in Reliance Standard Life Case and Awards Benefits to Claimant

Wednesday, February 4th, 2015

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, on appeal from the Federal District Court in Texas (a very conservative Court), has reversed a decision in favor of an insurer, Reliance Standard Life Insurance Company, and has granted benefits to a claimant, where it determined that the claim decision was an abuse of discretion, as it was not supported by substantial evidence.

Reliance Standard had determined that no further benefits were payable to claimant, on two separate grounds. First, it determined that the claimant had both a physical and mental impairment, and relying upon policy language which noted a limited pay period where a mental health impairment either caused or contributed to a disability, Reliance Standard ceased paying benefits. Reliance Standard claimed that it had paid the maximum benefit of 24 months for such conditions.

Second, Reliance Standard determined that the claimant no longer met the definition of disability, as it determined the claimant could perform sedentary work, and was thus disqualified from further benefits.

As to the issue of whether the limited benefit period applied for the mental health impairment, the Court of Appeals determined that because the claimant’s physical condition rendered him totally disabled, the language of the policy stating contributing to was not sufficient to cause a termination of benefits.

This is quite significant, as many claimants who are suffering from a myriad of health conditions often have secondary depression or anxiety, and a determination could often be made by insurers that the broad “caused or contributed” to language could act as a bar to benefits beyond the limited benefit period.

As to the issue of the ability to work in some occupation, the Court of Appeals determined that it was improper for Reliance Standard to reject the claimant’s evidence on the basis that it was not supported by any vocational expert.

The Court of Appeals also determined that Reliance Standard attempted to ignore the policy language which required the claimant to be able to earn a similar income to his prior earnings. Simply determining that the claimant had sedentary functional capacity was not sufficient, per the Court of Appeals.

Thus, the Court of Appeals concluded that “there is no rational connection between the fact that [he] could do sedentary work, including the alternative occupations, and the conclusion that [he] could earn a substantially similar salary in any alternative position.”

Accordingly, and despite a dissent from one Judge, the Court granted benefits to the claimant, and permitted the claimant to seek prejudgment interest and attorney’s fees and expenses.

George v. Reliance Standard Life Insurance Company

Jason A. Newfield

Written By:

Jason A. Newfield - Disability Insurance Attorney

Jason Newfield is a founding partner of the disability insurance law firm Frankel & Newfield. He has spent the majority of his legal career advocating for the rights of disabled workers. He has lectured other professionals, worked on a Federal Advisory committee, and published many articles in the field of disability insurance claims and litigation.

Learn more about Jason | See Jason’s Publications



Ready To Talk?

Fill out the form to request a FREE legal consultation

Sorry, we do not handle SSDI/Social Security claims.

Frankel & Newfield does not currently handle any Social Security Disability Insurance claims.


*Required fields are marked

I have read the disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


This is about a Social Security Disability claim.

Ipad image

Download Our Free eBook


Secrets the Disability Insurance Companies Don't Want You to know!

Sign Up for our mailing list to receive disability insurance law updates

Your information is 100% secure and will never be shared with anyone


No matter where you are nationwide, we are here to help.

We have the resources and support to take on the largest insurance companies.

Contact us today for our nationwide service.

Contact Us
Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi Missouri
Nebraska Nevada New Hampshire New Jersey New York North Carolina North Dakota Ohio Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina
South Dakota Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming