We do not handle social security disability claims

Court Schedules Trial in ERISA Disability Case against Aetna

Another Federal Court has adopted the approach of conducting a trial in an ERISA disability insurance benefits case, increasing the trend which only several years ago was unheard of.

A Court in West Virginia has determined that “because there are numerous genuine issues of material fact which conflicting inferences may be drawn from the evidence and reasonable men may reach different conclusions”, both parties’ motions for judgment were denied, and a bench trial is to be held.

This case presents many parallels to our firm’s case of Barber v. Sun Life where a Federal Judge in Connecticut has scheduled a bench trial with live witnesses to be heard. Over the strong objections of Sun Life, Judge Covello has determined a trial is required to decide whether Sun Life’s termination of our client’s claim was an abuse of discretion.

Here, the Federal Judge in West Virginia has determined that the trier of fact must determine whether Aetna relied on substantial conflicting medical evidence in denying coverage. The Court determined that a genuine issue of fact existed as to whether there was sufficient conflicting medical evidence to discount (as typically occurs) the treating doctor’s opinion regarding impairment.

In addition, the Court determined that there was a disputed issue of material fact concerning whether Aetna properly evaluated the objective medical evidence including MRIs and the weight to be applied to this evidence.

Dupell v. Aetna

Download Our Free eBook


Secrets the Disability Insurance Companies Don’t Want You to know!

Download Now
Super Lawyers | Justin 10.0Justin Corey Frankel
Justin Corey Frankel
Super Lawyers | Jason 9.7Jason Adam Newfield
Avvo | 10.0 | Top Attorney | Justin
Jason Adam Newfield


  • tick

    No matter where you are nationwide, we are here to help.

  • tick

    We have the resources and support to take on the largest insurance companies.

  • tick

    Contact us today for our nationwide service. Contact Us

logo celebratingFN
585 Stewart Ave., Suite 312
Garden City, NY 11530

Frankel & Newfield, P.C.
Toll Free: 877-583-2524
Fax: 516-222-0513
Map & Directions