Frankel & Newfield, P.C.

We Have Recovered Over $100 Million In Claims For Our Clients

Call for a Free Consult 866-504-8773
WE DO NOT HANDLE SOCIAL SECURITY DISABILITY CLAIMS

AETNA CLAIM DECISION LACKS SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE

A Federal Judge has demonstrated that despite a favorable standard of review for an insurance company, a claim decision must be supported by substantial evidence, or it will be reversed. Aetna reached a claim determination on the purported basis of medical reviews performed by its in house physician and an outside physician consultant, neither of whom examined or evaluated the claimant.

The Court carefully considered the substance of the reports relied upon by Aetna, and determined that these reports lacked substantial evidence, due to the selective inclusion of information, and the failure to consider support for the impairment from the claimant's treating medical providers, coupled with the mischaracterization of the medical findings by another hired physician.

The Court noted the value of a physical examination to a reliable assessment of a claimant's disability. The Court chastised Aetna for searching for a reason to deny benefits, where Aetna blindly accepted the paper review conclusions over the opinions of treating physicians, without meaningful explanations as to why.

Unfortunately, this decision is more the exception than the rule, and all too often, insurers are permitted to engage in like conduct, without meaningful scrutiny by the Courts. Often, the courts determine that it was appropriate for an insurer to rely upon these "independent" physicians, or even to rely upon in house doctors who do not even practice medicine on patients, fail to conduct an examination of the claimant and demand objective evidence, even where the policy does not contain such a requirement.

Download Our Free Ebook

E-book Download Book
Super Lawyers | Justin AV Preeminent | Justin Avvo | 10.0 | Top Attorney | Justin Super Lawyers | Jason AV Preeminent | Jason Avvo | 9.8 | Top Attorney | Jason

HELPING THE DISABLED NATIONWIDE

  • tick

    No matter where you are nationwide, we are here to help.

  • tick

    We have the resources and support to take on the largest insurance companies.

  • tick

    Contact us today for our nationwide service. Contact Us

FN

Frankel & Newfield, P.C.
585 Stewart Avenue
Suite 312
Garden City, NY 11530

Toll Free: 866-504-8773
Fax: 516-222-0513
Map & Directions